Sunday, November 21, 2010

Who Are The Tech Press Darlings?

Innovation Journalism Vol. 7 No. 7,  21 Nov 2010

By Morten Bay

Who Are The Tech Press Darlings? 
An Empirical Stidy of Coverage of Innovation-Driven Tech Companies in US Newspapers.

This paper contains a small study of empirical data collected between April 19, 2010 and May 19, 2010. The data is the five largest newspapers’ coverage of the ten largest innovation-driven technology companies in the US. The study is presented as a description of the current state of the presence of Innovation Journalism in American mainstream media. Newspapers have been chosen due to the fact that even though they are losing ground to web, mobile, tv and radio, newspapers still produce the vast majority of news stories proliferated through other media in the US.

The study shows an significant imbalance in coverage. There is a tendency towards coverage of two specific companies, Apple and Google. The difference between their presence in the newspapers, and the amount of coverage given to their competition is quite substantial, with the closest competitor, Microsoft, only obtaining approximately half of the coverage that the two companies get.

In the study, network mapping analysis is used to link journalists to companies in order to find out whether there are certain groups of journalists (e.g. specialized tech reporters) that help create imbalance by focusing on only a few innovators, or if –as is the case – it is a widespread tendency among all the journalists to cover Apple and Google more than others. The network mapping analysis is useful for identifying hubs, nodes in the network that are more connected than others, in this case either documenting that one journalist covers tech on a regular basis, or whether one journalist writes more positive stories about a company than negative stories.

The study also shows that positive stories are dominant. There is an approximate 20-30 percent difference in favor of the positive stories, sometimes even more. It is discussed whether this lack of balance and critical journalism is actually good for Innovation Journalism or not. Some argue that a positive slant works to build social capital for innovation in general, while others argue that not following ethical guidelines in Innovation Journalism actually diminishes coverage of the innovators and innovations that aren’t necessarily fashionable or popular at a given time – which creates an imbalance like the one we see towards Google and Apple.

Finally, it is discussed what creates an imbalance like the present one, and how to find a solution to the problem. It is argued that it is the success of building an effective reputation and a lovable brand through non-traditional PR and advertising that gives Google and Apple the edge. Towards the end, this paper criticizes journalists for not trying to even out the balance, and seeks to find a reason why a more balanced coverage is not available to the public. It is argued that a self-reinforcing media hype, which stems from the effective attention work of Apple and Google, also has a blinding effect on journalists, creating the illusion that Apple and Google are all the public cares about – giving the editorial decision-makers a reason to cover them more.


David said...

All guys love to travel, especially to the sea. But when you are in college, there is not enough time for that. I found a way to save time and effort in my studies, and this is a site where they provide custom essay help. Now I can travel and still get great college grades!

NovaClinic said...

We are proud to be ranked among the top cosmetic surgery clinics in Dubai. We are focused and dedicated to not only meet but also exceed the expectations of our clients and provide them with the results that they always wanted.
tummy tuck


renee said...

However, innovation communications cannot be seen as impartial as the word innovation is one of the worlds most utilized in business communications as such. Martin custom logo design service

Daniel Lisa said...

Very nice article I really loved it well if you face quickbooks error 1328 while operating company file just rename your nd file with .old extension.

Al Shunnar Plastic Surgery said...

Are you looking for the best plastic and cosmetic surgery clinic in Dubai? Al Shunnar Plastic Surgery offers you the best cosmetic and plastic surgery in Dubai, UAE with a team of expert professionals. Following facial procedures are popular amongst the people.
Facelift in Dubai
Rhinoplasty is Dubai
Blepharoplasty in Dubai
Buccal Fat Removal in Dubai

Nancy said...

Very nice article. If you do work related to accounts you must have heard of Quickbooks many issues have been reported by QuickBooks customers, one of which being QuickBooks error 15241. When a user tries to download or update the payroll services, this error usually happens. Another cause of this error could be that the QuickBooks Desktop File Copy Service (FCS) is turned off. The QuickBooks payroll update problem code 15241 can be quite inconvenient for users to deal with.

William acker said...

Thank you for this blog .If you use Quickbooks software and face any issue about this and want to resolve your Problem click and read quickbooks install diagnostic tool

nik jones said...

Thanks for sharing superb knowledge with us. Your thought is very impressive. If you are a QuickBooks user and facing an error, if you need any help, so contact our QuickBooks Expert for solving your problem.

QuickBooks Error 3371 Status Code 11118

david warner said...

since virtual accounting firm firms provide significant benefits for their clients' data retention requirements because they only keep digital copies of their clients' records. Virtual firms typically scan all sensitive tax documents, allowing clients easy access to historical tax returns and copies of supporting documentation without the need to keep physical copies.

DavidRSanchez451 said...

Thanks for sharing superb knowledge with us. Your thought is very impressive. If you are Facing Cyber Attack, if you need any help, so contact malwarebytes coupon code for solving your problem.

The Bride Side said...

When booking Edinburgh Wedding Hair and Makeup services, brides can expect a consultation to discuss their vision and preferences for their wedding day look. This allows stylists and makeup artists to tailor their services to each individual bride, ensuring that the final result exceeds expectations.

Whether the bride desires a glamorous, red-carpet-worthy style or a soft, romantic look, wedding hair and makeup Edinburgh professionals have the skills and expertise to bring any vision to life. By choosing Edinburgh Wedding Hair and Makeup services, brides can relax and enjoy the pampering experience of having their hair and makeup done professionally, knowing that they are in capable hands for their wedding day.